Case #1093 — Marlow London
marycullen424@gmail.com · order 2246 · state imported · label none yet · rung 0
Facts
New customer message on 30 July 2026 at 21:23
open
not set
2026-07-30 20:24:18
—
2026-08-14 19:30:08
Engine shadow decision
No shadow decision recorded yet — either the engine hasn't classified this case, or cs_shadow_decisions hasn't been created yet (p2-engine in progress).
Latest draft
from decision #2676 · action=reply · 2026-08-02 21:32:48 · dry-run
Hi Mary,
I am very sorry for the wrong size. You ordered size 9 and we sent size 40 - that is our error, and I understand why you want to return it.
Since we made this mistake in fulfilling your order, here are your options:
1. I can process a full refund to your original payment method within 3 to 5 business days, and you can keep the shoes.
2. I can arrange a free replacement in the correct size (size 9) to the same address, and you can keep the shoes you received as well.
Which would you prefer? Just reply and I will get it sorted straight away.
Warm regards,
Anna
Customer Care Team
Marlow London
Reasoning: [re-run vs new playbook 2026-08-02] Customer explicitly rejected exchange and asked for refund guidance after our fulfillment error (wrong size sent). Offering both full refund and free replacement as appropriate remedies.
Compose / edit reply
Set your name at the top of the page before you can compose or edit a reply — every write here is attributed to that name in the audit log.
Escalate to a human
Set your name at the top of the page before you can escalate this case — every write here is attributed to that name in the audit log.
Raise a supplier request
Set your name at the top of the page before you can raise a supplier request — every write here is attributed to that name in the audit log.
Money action — admin only
Set your name at the top of the page before you can run a money action — every write here is attributed to that name in the audit log.
Actions on this thread
No pending/executed actions for this thread.
Case events
No case events logged yet.
Full thread
You received a new message from your online store's contact form.
Country Code:
GB
Name:
Mary Cullen
Email:
marycullen424@gmail.com
Body:
Good Evening,
I received my order today and am very disappointed to note that
the shoes are a size 40 - this is NOT what I ordered, if you
check my order number 2246, you will see ordered a size 9 or a
42/43 , please advise how I return for a refund.
Hi there,
I have checked with our manufacturer and confirmed that your order was part of a faulty batch, which is completely unacceptable, and we are noting it so it does not happen again.
Good news! I can see your order 2246, and we've arranged a free replacement in the correct size for you.
You can keep the one you already have, for a small contribution of £4.95, and there's nothing to send back. Just let me know which size you'd like instead and I will get that sorted for you right away.
If you'd rather not exchange, just let me know and I can look at other options too.
Warm regards,
Anna
Customer Care Team
Marlow London
Hi Anna
I don't want a pair of shoes that don't fit me! Please advise how I return
them.
Please also advise how I obtain a refund.
Thank you
Mary
On Thu, 30 Jul 2026 at 21:25, <support@marlow-london.com> wrote:
> Hi there,
>
> I have checked with our manufacturer and confirmed that your order was
> part of a faulty batch, which is completely unacceptable, and we are noting
> it so it does not happen again.
>
> Good news! I can see your order 2246, and we've arranged a free
> replacement in the correct size for you.
>
> You can keep the one you already have, for a small contribution of £4.95,
> and there's nothing to send back. Just let me know which size you'd like
> instead and I will get that sorted for you right away.
>
> If you'd rather not exchange, just let me know and I can look at other
> options too.
>
> Warm regards,
> Anna
> Customer Care Team
> Marlow London
>
Hi
Can I have a response to my email please?
On Thu, 30 Jul 2026 at 21:25, <support@marlow-london.com> wrote:
> Hi there,
>
> I have checked with our manufacturer and confirmed that your order was
> part of a faulty batch, which is completely unacceptable, and we are noting
> it so it does not happen again.
>
> Good news! I can see your order 2246, and we've arranged a free
> replacement in the correct size for you.
>
> You can keep the one you already have, for a small contribution of £4.95,
> and there's nothing to send back. Just let me know which size you'd like
> instead and I will get that sorted for you right away.
>
> If you'd rather not exchange, just let me know and I can look at other
> options too.
>
> Warm regards,
> Anna
> Customer Care Team
> Marlow London
>
Hi Mary,
I'm sorry for the wait on this. I can confirm order #2246 has already been refunded to you in full - there's nothing further you need to do and no need to send the shoes back, please keep them.
If it hasn't shown on your statement within 3 to 5 business days of when it was processed, let me know and I'll chase it up.
I'm sorry the replacement offer wasn't the right fit for you, and for the trouble this caused.
Warm regards,
Anna
Customer Care Team
Marlow London